Thursday, December 27, 2012
Monday, December 24, 2012
Steps in Cash Flow Estimation
Estimate the current earnings of the firm
• If looking at cash flows to equity, look at earnings after interest expenses - i.e. net income
• If looking at cash flows to the firm, look at operating earnings after taxes
Consider how much the firm invested to create future growth
• If the investment is not expensed, it will be categorized as capital expenditures. To the extent that depreciation provides a cash flow, it will cover some of these expenditures.
• Increasing working capital needs are also investments for future growth
If looking at cash flows to equity, consider the cash flows from net debt issues (debt issued - debt repaid)
EBIT ( 1 - tax rate)
- (Capital Expenditures - Depreciation)
- Change in Working Capital
= Cash flow to the firm
Where are the tax savings from interest payments in this cash flow?
From Reported to Actual Earnings
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Estimating the Cost of Debt
The cost of debt is the rate at which you can borrow at currently, It will reflect not only your default risk but also the level of interest rates in the market.
The two most widely used approaches to estimating cost of debt are:
• Looking up the yield to maturity on a straight bond outstanding from the firm. The limitation of this approach is that very few firms have long term straight bonds that are liquid and widely traded.
• Looking up the rating for the firm and estimating a default spread based upon the rating. While this approach is more robust, different bonds from the same firm can have different ratings. You have to use a median rating for the firm
When in trouble (either because you have no ratings or multiple ratings for a firm), estimate a synthetic rating for your firm and the cost of debt based upon that rating. The rating for a firm can be estimated using the financial characteristics of the firm. In its simplest form, the rating can be estimated from the interest
coverage ratio.
Interest Coverage Ratio = EBIT / Interest Expenses
Companies in countries with low bond ratings and high default risk might bear the burden of country default risk, especially if they are smaller or have all of their revenues within the country.
Larger companies that derive a significant portion of their revenues in global markets may be less exposed to country default risk. In other words, they may be able to borrow at a rate lower than the government.
The weights used to compute the cost of capital should be the market value weights for debt and equity.
There is an element of circularity that is introduced into every valuation by doing this, since the values that we attach to the firm and equity at the end of the analysis are different from the values we gave them at the beginning.
As a general rule, the debt that you should subtract from firm value to arrive at the value of equity should be the same debt that you used to compute the cost of capital.
Sunday, October 14, 2012
Estimating Beta
The standard procedure for estimating betas is to regress stock returns (Rj) against market returns (Rm) -
Rj = a + b Rm
• where a is the intercept and b is the slope of the regression.
The slope of the regression corresponds to the beta of the stock, and measures the riskiness of the stock. This beta has three problems:
• It has high standard error
• It reflects the firm’s business mix over the period of the regression, not the current mix
• It reflects the firm’s average financial leverage over the period rather than the current leverage.
Solutions to the Regression Beta Problem
Modify the regression beta by
• changing the index used to estimate the beta
• adjusting the regression beta estimate, by bringing in information about the fundamentals of the company
Estimate the beta for the firm using
• the standard deviation in stock prices instead of a regression against an index
• accounting earnings or revenues, which are less noisy than market prices.
Estimate the beta for the firm from the bottom up without employing the regression technique. This will require
• understanding the business mix of the firm
• estimating the financial leverage of the firm
Use an alternative measure of market risk not based upon a regression
Within any business, firms with lower fixed costs (as a percentage of total costs) should have lower unlevered betas. If you can compute fixed and variable costs for each firm in a sector, you can break down the unlevered beta into business and operating leverage components.
Unlevered beta = Pure business beta * (1 + (Fixed costs/ Variable costs))
The biggest problem with doing this is informational. It is difficult to get information on fixed and variable costs for individual firms. In practice, we tend to assume that the operating leverage of firms within a business are similar and use the same unlevered beta for every firm.
Calculating Equity Betas and Leverage
βL = βu (1+ ((1-t)D/E))
In some versions, the tax effect is ignored and there is no (1-t) in the equation. Debt Adjusted Approach: If beta carries market risk and you can estimate the beta of debt, you can estimate the levered beta as follows
βL = βu (1+ ((1-t)D/E)) - βdebt (1-t) (D/E)
While the latter is more realistic, estimating betas for debt can be difficult to do.
Thursday, April 5, 2012
Estimating Discount Rates
Critical ingredient in discounted cash flow valuation. Errors in estimating the discount rate or mismatching cash flows and discount rates can lead to serious errors in valuation. At an intuitive level, the discount rate used should be consistent with both the riskiness and the type of cash-flow being discounted. If the cash flows being discounted are cash flows to equity, the appropriate discount rate is a cost of equity. If the cash flows are cash flows to the firm, the appropriate discount rate is the cost of capital. The currency in which the cash flows are estimated should also be the currency in which the discount rate is estimated. If the cash flows being discounted are nominal cash flows (i.e., reflect expected inflation), the discount rate should be nominal.
The cost of equity should be higher for riskier investments and lower for safer investments.While risk is usually defined in terms of the variance of actual returns around an expected return, risk and return models in finance assume that the risk that should be rewarded (and thus built into the discount rate) in valuation should
be the risk perceived by the marginal investor in the investment. Most risk and return models in finance also assume that the marginal investor is well diversified, and that the only risk that he or she perceives in an
investment is risk that cannot be diversified away (I.e, market or non-diversifiable risk).
There are various models to calculate cost of Equity, however the most popular one being CAPM
Consider the standard approach to estimating cost of equity:
Cost of Equity = Rf + Equity Beta * (E(Rm) - Rf)
where,
Rf = Riskfree rate
E(Rm) = Expected Return on the Market Index (Diversified Portfolio)
In practice, Short term government security rates are used as risk free rates, Historical risk premiums are used for the risk premium & Betas are estimated by regressing stock returns against market returns.
On a risk-free asset, the actual return is equal to the expected return. Therefore, there is no variance around the expected return. For an investment to be riskfree, then, it has to have a) No default risk b) No reinvestment risk. Thus, the riskfree rates in valuation will depend upon when the cash flow is expected to occur and will vary across time. In valuation, the time horizon is generally infinite, leading to the conclusion
that a long-term riskfree rate will always be preferable to a short term rate, if you have to pick one.
But what happens in a situation like that in Greece, where there is no riskfree/default free assest to be found, how do we then estimate a Riskfree Rate when there are no default free entities.
-Approach 1: Subtract default spread from local government bond rate: Government bond rate in local currency terms - Default spread for Government in local currency.
-Approach 2: Use forward rates and the riskless rate in an index currency (say Euros or dollars) to estimate the riskless rate in the local currency.
Do the analysis in real terms (rather than nominal terms) using a real riskfree rate, which can be obtained in one of two ways –
• from an inflation-indexed government bond, if one exists
• set equal, approximately, to the long term real growth rate of the economy in which the valuation is being done.
Do the analysis in a currency where you can get a riskfree rate, say US dollars.
Friday, December 2, 2011
Valuation in different scenarios
Valuation in Acquisition Analysis:
Valuation should play a central part of acquisition analysis. The bidding firm or individual has to decide on a fair value for the target firm before making a bid, and the target firm has to determine a reasonable value for itself before deciding to accept or reject the offer. There are special factors to consider in takeover valuation. First, there is synergy, the increase in value that many managers foresee as occurring after mergers because the combined firm is able to accomplish things that the individual firms could not. The effects of synergy on the combined value of the two firms (target plus bidding firm) have to be considered before a decision is made on the bid. Second, the value of control, which measures the effects on value of changing management and restructuring the target firm, will have to be taken into account in deciding on a fair price. This is of particular concern in hostile takeovers. As we noted earlier, there is a significant problem with bias in takeover valuations. Target firms may be over-optimistic in estimating value, especially when the takeover is hostile, and they are trying to convince their stockholders that the offer price is too low. Similarly, if the bidding firm has decided, for strategic reasons, to do an acquisition, there may be strong pressure on the analyst to come up with an estimate of value that backs up the acquisition.
Valuation in Corporate Finance:
There is a role for valuation at every stage of a firm’s life cycle. For small private businesses thinking about expanding, valuation plays a key role when they approach venture capital and private equity investors for more capital. The share of a firm that a venture capitalist will demand in exchange for a capital infusion will depend upon the value she estimates for the firm. As the companies get larger and decide to go public,
valuations determine the prices at which they are offered to the market in the public offering. Once established, decisions on where to invest, how much to borrow and how much to return to the owners will be all decisions that are affected by valuation. If the objective in corporate finance is to maximize firm value, the relationship between financial decisions, corporate strategy and firm value has to be delineated. As a final note, value enhancement has become the mantra of management consultants and CEOs who want to keep stockholders happy, and doing it right requires an understanding of the levers of value. In fact, many consulting firms have come up with their own measures of value (EVA and CFROI, for instance) that they contend facilitate value enhancement.
Thursday, October 20, 2011
Applicability of multiples and limitations
The allure of multiples is that they are simple and easy to relate to. They can be used to obtain estimates of value quickly for firms and assets, and are particularly useful when there are a large number of comparable firms being traded on financial markets, and the market is, on average, pricing these firms correctly. In fact, relative valuation is tailor made for analysts and portfolio managers who not only have to find under valued equities in any market, no matter how overvalued, but also get judged on a relative basis. An analyst who picks stocks based upon their PE ratios, relative to the sectors they operate in, will always find under valued stocks in any market; if entire sectors are over valued and his stocks decline, he will still look good on a relative basis since his stocks will decline less than comparable stocks(assuming the relative valuation is right). By the same token, they are also easy to misuse and manipulate, especially when comparable firms are used. Given that no two firms are exactly similar in terms of risk and growth, the definition of 'comparable' firms is a subjective one. Consequently, a biased analyst can choose a group of comparable firms to confirm his or her biases about a firm's value. While this potential for bias exists with discounted cash flow valuation as well, the analyst in DCF valuation is forced to be much more explicit about the assumptions which determine the final value. With multiples, these assumptions are often left unstated. The other problem with using multiples based upon comparable firms is that it builds in errors (over valuation or under valuation) that the market might be making in valuing these firms. If, for instance, we find a company to be under valued because it trades at 15 times earnings and comparable companies trade at 25 times earnings, we may still lose on the investment if the entire sector is over valued. In relative valuation, all that we can claim isthat a stock looks cheap or expensive relative to the group we compared it to, rather than make an absolute judgement about value. Ultimately, relative valuation judgements depend upon how well we have picked the comparable companies and how how good a job the market has done in pricing them.
Friday, August 26, 2011
Relative Valuation
While the focus in classrooms and academic discussions remains on discounted cash flow valuation, the reality is that most assets are valued on a relative basis. In relative valuation, we value an asset by looking at how the market prices similar assets. Thus, when determining what to pay for a house, we look at what similar houses in the neighbor hood sold for rather than doing an intrinsic valuation. Extending this analogy to
stocks, investors often decide whether a stock is cheap or expensive by comparing its pricing to that of similar stocks (usually in its peer group). In this section, we will consider the basis for relative valuation, waysin which it can be used and its advantages and disadvantages. Basis for approach In relative valuation, the value of an asset is derived from the pricing of 'comparable' assets, standardized using a common variable. Included in this description are two key components of relative valuation. The first is the notion of comparable or similar assets. From a valuation standpoint, this would imply assets with similar cash flows, risk and growth potential. In practice, it is usually taken to mean other companies that are in the same business as the company being valued. The other is a standardized price. After all, the price per share of a company is in some sense arbitrary since it is a function of the number of shares outstanding; a two for one stock split would halve the price. Dividing the price or market value by some measure that is related to that value will yield a standardized price. When valuing stocks, this essentially translates into using multiples where we divide the market value by earnings, book value or revenues to arrive at an estimate of standardized value. We can then compare these numbers across companies.
company. Harking back to our earlier discussion of discounted cash flow valuation, we argued that discounted cash flow valuation was a search (albeit unfulfilled) for intrinsic value. In relative valuation, we have given up on estimating intrinsic value and essentially put our trust in markets getting it right, at least on average.
Variations on Relative Valuation In relative valuation, the value of an asset is based upon how similar assets are priced. In practice, there are three variations on relative valuation, with the differences primarily in how we define comparable firms and control for differences across firms:
a. Direct comparison: In this approach, analysts try to find one or two companies that look almost exactly like the company they are trying to value and estimate the value based upon how these “similar” companies are priced. The key part in this analysis is identifying these similar companies and getting their market values.
b. Peer Group Average: In the second, analysts compare how their company is priced(using a multiple) with how the peer group is priced (using the average for that multiple). Thus, a stock is considered cheap if it trade at 12 times earnings and the average price earnings ratio for the sector is 15. Implicit in this approach is the assumption that while companies may vary widely across a sector, the average for the sector is representative for a typical company.
c. Peer group average adjusted for differences Recognizing that there can be wide differences between the company being valued and other companies in the comparable firm group, analysts sometimes try to control for differences between companies. In many cases, the control is subjective: a company with higher expected growth than the industry will trade at a higher multiple of earnings than the industry average but how much higher is left unspecified. In a few cases, analysts explicitly try to control for differences between companies by either adjusting the multiple being used or by using statistical techniques. As an example of the former, consider PEG ratios. These ratios are computed by dividing PE ratios by expected growth rates, thus controlling (at least in theory) for differences in growth and allowing analysts to compare companies with
different growth rates. For statistical controls, we can use a multiple regression where we can regress the multiple that we are using against the fundamentals that we believe cause that multiple to vary across companies. The resulting regression can be used to estimate the value of an individual company. In fact, we will argue later in this book that statistical techniques are powerful enough to allow us to expand the comparable firm sample to include the entire market.
Saturday, July 30, 2011
DCF Valuation- Pluses and Minuses
To true believers, discounted cash flow valuation is the only way to approach valuation, but the benefits may be more nuanced that they are willing to admit. On the plus side, discounted cash flow valuation, done right, requires analysts to understand the businesses that they are valuing and ask searching questions about the sustainability of cash flows and risk. Discounted cash flow valuation is tailor made for those who buy into
the Warren Buffett adage that what we are buying are not stocks but the underlying businesses. In addition, discounted cash flow valuations is inherently contrarian in the sense that it forces analysts to look for the fundamentals that drive value rather than what market perceptions are.Consequently, if stock prices rise (fall) disproportionately relative to the underlying earnings and cash flows, discounted cash flows models are likely to find stocks to be over valued (under valued). There are, however, limitations with discounted cash flow valuation. In the hands of sloppy analysts, discounted cash flow valuations can be manipulated to generate
estimates of value that have no relationship to intrinsic value. We also need substantially more information to value a company with discounted cash flow models, since we have to estimate cash flows, growth rates and discount rates. Finally, discounted cash flow models may very well find every stock in a sector or even a market to be over valued, if market perceptions have run ahead of fundamentals. For portfolio managers and equity research analysts, who are required to find equities to buy even in the most over valued markets, this creates a conundrum. They can go with their discounted cash flow valuations and conclude that everything is overvalued, which may put them out of business, or they can find an alternate approach that is more sensitive to market moods. It should come as no surprise that many choose the latter.
Saturday, July 2, 2011
Inputs to Discounted Cash Flow Models
There are three inputs that are required to value any asset in this model - the expected cash flow, the timing of the cash flow and the discount rate that is appropriate given the riskiness of these cash flows. While we will be looking at discount rate and cash flow estimation in far more detail in the coming chapters, we will lay out the fundamentals in this section.
a. Discount Rates
In valuation, we begin with the fundamental notion that the discount rate used on a cash flow should reflect its riskiness, with higher risk cash flows having higher discount rates. There are two ways of viewing risk. The first is purely in terms of the likelihood that an entity will default on a commitment to make a payment, such as interest or principal due, and this is called default risk. When looking at debt, the cost of debt is the
rate that reflects this default risk. The second way of viewing risk is in terms of the variation of actual returns
around expected returns. The actual returns on a risky investment can be very different from expected returns; the greater the variation, the greater the risk. When looking at equity, we tend to use measures of risk based upon return variance. While the next chapter will look at the different models that attempt to do this in far more detail, there are some basic points on which these models agree. The first is that risk in an investment has to perceived through the eyes of the marginal investor in that investment, and this marginal investor is assumed to be well diversified across multiple investments. Therefore, the risk in an investment that should determine discount rates is the non diversifiable or market risk of that investment. The second is that the expected return on any investment can be obtained starting with the expected return on a risk-less investment, and adding to it a premium to reflect the amount of market risk in that investment. This expected return yields the cost of equity.
The cost of capital can be obtained by taking an average of the cost of equity, estimated as above, and the after-tax cost of borrowing, based upon default risk, and weighting by the proportions used by each. We will argue that the weights used, when valuing an on-going business, should be based upon the market values of debt and equity. While there are some analysts who use book value weights, doing so violates a basic principle of valuation, which is that at a fair value, one should be indifferent between buying and selling an asset.
b. Expected Cash Flows
In the strictest sense, the only cash flow an equity investor gets out of a publicly traded firm is the dividend; models that use the dividends as cash flows are called dividend discount models. A broader definition of cash flows to equity would be the cash flows left over after the cash flow claims of non-equity investors in the firm have been met (interest and principal payments to debt holders and preferred dividends) and after enough of these cash flows has been reinvested into the firm to sustain the projected growth in cash flows. This is the free cash flow to equity (FCFE), and models that use these cash flows are called FCFE discount models. The cash flow to the firm is the cumulated cash flow to all claim holders in the firm. One way to obtain this cash flow is to add the free cash flows to equity to the cash flows to lenders (debt) and preferred stockholders. A far simpler way of obtaining the same number is to estimate the cash flows prior to debt and preferred dividend payments, by subtracting from the after-tax operating income the net investment needs to sustain growth. This cash flow is called the free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) and the models that use these cash flows are called FCFF models.
c. Expected Growth
It is while estimating the expected growth in cash flows in the future that analysts confront uncertainty most directly. There are three generic ways of estimating growth. One is to look at a company’s past and use the historical growth rate posted by that company. The peril is that past growth may provide little indication of future growth. The second is to obtain estimates of growth from more informed sources. For some analysts,
this translates into using the estimates provided by a company’s management whereas for others it takes the form of using consensus estimates of growth made by others who follow the firm. The bias associated with both these sources should raise questions about the resulting valuations. We will promote a third way, where the expected growth rate is tied to two variables that are determined by the firm being valued - how much of the earnings are reinvested back into the firm and how well those earnings are reinvested. In the equity
valuation model, this expected growth rate is a product of the retention ratio, i.e. the proportion of net income not paid out to stockholders, and the return on equity on the projects taken with that money. In the firm valuation model, the expected growth rate is a product of the reinvestment rate, which is the proportion of after-tax operating income that goes into net new investments and the return on capital earned on these investments. The advantages of using these fundamental growth rates are two fold. The first is that the
resulting valuations will be internally consistent and companies that are assumed to have high growth are required to pay for the growth with more reinvestment. The second is that it lays the foundation for considering how firms can make themselves more valuable to their investors.
Thursday, May 12, 2011
Variations on DCF Models
The model that we have presented in this section, where expected cash flows are discounted back at a risk-adjusted discount rate, is the most commonly used discounted cash flow approach but there are two widely used variants. In the first, we separate the cash flows into excess return cash flows and normal return cash flows. Earning the risk adjusted required return (cost of capital or equity)is considered a normal return cash flow but any cash flows above or below this number are categorized as excess returns; excess returns can therefore be either positive or negative. With the excess return valuation framework, the value of a business can be written as the sum of two components:
Value of business = Capital Invested in firm today + Present value of excess return cash flows from both existing and future projects
If we make the assumption that the accounting measure of capital invested (book value of capital) is a good measure of capital invested in assets today, this approach implies that firms that earn positive excess return cash flows will trade at market values higher than their book values and that the reverse will be true for firms that earn negative excess return cash flows.
In the second variation, called the adjusted present value (APV) approach, we separate the effects on value of debt financing from the value of the assets of a business. In general, using debt to fund a firm’s operations creates tax benefits (because interest expenses are tax deductible) on the plus side and increases bankruptcy risk (and expected bankruptcy costs) on the minus side. In the APV approach, the value of a firm can be
written as follows:
Value of business = Value of business with 100% equity financing + Present value of Expected Tax Benefits of Debt – Expected Bankruptcy Costs
In contrast to the conventional approach, where the effects of debt financing are captured in the discount rate, the APV approach attempts to estimate the expected dollar value of debt benefits and costs separately from the value of the operating assets.While proponents of each approach like to claim that their approach is the best and most precise, P.S that the three approaches yield the same estimates of value, if we make consistent assumptions.
Friday, March 18, 2011
Equity Valuation versus Firm Valuation
There are two ways in which we can approach discounted cash flow valuation. The first is to value the entire business, with both assets-in-place and growth assets; this is often termed firm or enterprise valuation.
The cash flows before debt payments and after reinvestment needs are called free cash flows to the firm, and the discount rate that reflects the composite cost of financing from all sources of capital is called the cost of capital. The second way is to just value the equity stake in the business, and this is called equity valuation.
The cash flows after debt payments and reinvestment needs are called free cash flows to equity, and the discount rate that reflects just the cost of equity financing is the cost of equity. Note also that we can always get from the former (firm value) to the latter (equity value) by netting out the value of all non-equity claims from firm value. Done right, the value of equity should be the same whether it is valued directly (by discounting cash flows to equity a the cost of equity) or indirectly (by valuing the firm and subtracting out the value of all non-equity claims).
Friday, January 14, 2011
Classifying Discounted Cash Flow Models
There are three distinct ways in which we can categorize discounted cash flow models. In the first, we differentiate between valuing a business as a going concern as opposed to a collection of assets. In the second, we draw a distinction between valuing the equity in a business and valuing the business itself. In the third, we lay out three different and equivalent ways of doing discounted cash flow valuation – the expected
cash flow approach, a value based upon excess returns and adjusted present value.
Going Concern versus Asset Valuation
The value of an asset in the discounted cash flow framework is the present value of the expected cash flows on that asset. Extending this proposition to valuing a business, it can be argued that the value of a business is the sum of the values of the individual assets owned by the business. While this may be technically right, there is a key difference between valuing a collection of assets and a business. A business or a company is an on-going entity with assets that it already owns and assets it expects to invest in the future.
Investments that have already been made are categorized as assets in place, but investments that we expect the business to make in the future are growth assets. A financial balance sheet provides a good framework to draw out the differences between valuing a business as a going concern and valuing it as a collection of assets. In a going concern valuation, we have to make our best judgments not only on existing investments but also on expected future investments and their profitability. While this may seem to be foolhardy, a large proportion of the market value of growth companies comes from their growth assets. In an asset-based valuation, we focus primarily on the assets in place and estimate the value of each asset separately. Adding the asset values together yields the value of the business. For companies with lucrative growth
opportunities, asset-based valuations will yield lower values than going concern valuations.
Tuesday, December 28, 2010
Approaches to Valuation
Analysts use a wide spectrum of models, ranging from the simple to the sophisticated. These models often make very different assumptions about the fundamentals that determine value, but they do share some common characteristics and can be classified in broader terms. There are several advantages to such a classification -- it makes it is easier to understand where individual models fit in to the big picture, why
they provide different results and when they have fundamental errors in logic. In general terms, there are three approaches to valuation. The first, discounted cash flow valuation, relates the value of an asset to the present value of expected future cash flows on that asset. The second, relative valuation, estimates the value of an asset by looking at the pricing of 'comparable' assets relative to a common variable like earnings, cash flows, book value or sales. The third, contingent claim valuation, uses option pricing models to measure the value of assets that share option characteristics. While they can yield different estimates of value, one of the objectives of this book is to explain the reasons for such differences, and to help in picking the right model to use for a specific task.
Discounted Cash-flow Valuation
In discounted cash flows valuation, the value of an asset is the present value of the expected cash flows on the asset, discounted back at a rate that reflects the riskiness of these cash flows. This approach gets the most play in classrooms and comes with the best theoretical credentials. In this section, we will look at the foundations of the approach and some of the preliminary details on how we estimate its inputs.
Basis for Approach
We buy most assets because we expect them to generate cash flows for us in the future. In discounted cash flow valuation, we begin with a simple proposition. The value of an asset is not what someone perceives it to be worth but it is a function of the expected cash flows on that asset. Put simply, assets with high and predictable cash flows should have higher values than assets with low and volatile cash flows. In discounted
cash flow valuation, we estimate the value of an asset as the present value of the expected cash flows on it.
The cash flows will vary from asset to asset -- dividends for stocks, coupons(interest) and the face value for bonds and after-tax cash flows for a business. The discount rate will be a function of the riskiness of the estimated cash flows, with higher rates for riskier assets and lower rates for safer ones.Using discounted cash flow models is in some sense an act of faith. We believe that every asset has an intrinsic value and we try to estimate that intrinsic value by looking at an asset’s fundamentals. What is intrinsic value? Consider it the value that would be attached to an asset by an all-knowing analyst with access to all information available right now and a perfect valuation model. No such analyst exists, of course, but we all aspire to be as close as we can to this perfect analyst. The problem lies in the fact that none of us ever gets to see what the true intrinsic value of an asset is and we therefore have no way of knowing whether our discounted cash flow valuations are close to the mark or not.
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
INTRODUCTION TO VALUATION
INTRODUCTION TO VALUATION
Knowing what an asset is worth and what determines that value is a pre-requisite for intelligent decision making -- in choosing investments for a portfolio, in deciding on the appropriate price to pay or receive in a takeover and in making investment, financing and dividend choices when running a business. The premise of this blog is that we can Emake reasonable estimates of value for most assets, and that the same fundamental
principles determine the values of all types of assets, real as well as financial. Some assets are easier to value than others, the details of valuation vary from asset to asset, and the uncertainty associated with value estimates is different for different assets, but the core principles remain the same. This chapter lays out some general insights about the valuation process and outlines the role that valuation plays in portfolio management,
acquisition analysis and in corporate finance. It also examines the three basic approaches that can be used to value an asset.
A philosophical basis for valuation A postulate of sound investing is that an investor does not pay more for an asset than it is worth. This statement may seem logical and obvious, but it is forgotten and rediscovered at some time in every generation and in every market. There are those who are disingenuous enough to argue that value is in the eyes of the beholder, and that any price can be justified if there are other investors willing to pay that price. That is patently absurd. Perceptions may be all that matter when the asset is a painting or a sculpture, but we do not and should not buy most assets for aesthetic or emotional reasons; we buy financial assets for the cash flows we expect to receive from them. Consequently, perceptions of value have to be backed up by reality, which implies that the price we pay for any asset should reflect the cash flows it is expected to generate. The models of valuation described in this book attempt to relate value to the level of, uncertainty about and expected growth in these cash flows.
There are many aspects of valuation where we can agree to disagree, including estimates of true value and how long it will take for prices to adjust to that true value. But there is one point on which there can be no disagreement. Asset prices cannot be justified by merely using the argument that there will be other investors around who will pay a higher price in the future. That is the equivalent of playing a very expensive game of
musical chairs, where every investor has to answer the question, "Where will I be when the music stops?” before playing. The problem with investing with the expectation that there will be a bigger fool around to sell an asset to, when the time comes, is that you might end up being the biggest fool of all.
Inside the Valuation Process
There are two extreme views of the valuation process. At one end are those who believe that valuation, done right, is a hard science, where there is little room for analyst views or human error. At the other are those who feel that valuation is more of an art, where savvy analysts can manipulate the numbers to generate whatever result they want. The truth does lies somewhere in the middle and we will use this section to consider three components of the valuation process that do not get the attention they deserve – the bias that analysts bring to the process, the uncertainty that they have to grapple with and the complexity that modern technology and easy access to information have introduced into valuation.
Value first, Valuation to follow: Bias in Valuation
We almost never start valuing a company with a blank slate. All too often, our views on a company are formed before we start inputting the numbers into the models that we use and not surprisingly, our conclusions tend to reflect our biases. We will begin by considering the sources of bias in valuation and then move on to evaluate how bias manifests itself in most valuations. We will close with a discussion of how best to minimize or at least deal with bias in valuations.
Knowing what an asset is worth and what determines that value is a pre-requisite for intelligent decision making -- in choosing investments for a portfolio, in deciding on the appropriate price to pay or receive in a takeover and in making investment, financing and dividend choices when running a business. The premise of this blog is that we can Emake reasonable estimates of value for most assets, and that the same fundamental
principles determine the values of all types of assets, real as well as financial. Some assets are easier to value than others, the details of valuation vary from asset to asset, and the uncertainty associated with value estimates is different for different assets, but the core principles remain the same. This chapter lays out some general insights about the valuation process and outlines the role that valuation plays in portfolio management,
acquisition analysis and in corporate finance. It also examines the three basic approaches that can be used to value an asset.
A philosophical basis for valuation A postulate of sound investing is that an investor does not pay more for an asset than it is worth. This statement may seem logical and obvious, but it is forgotten and rediscovered at some time in every generation and in every market. There are those who are disingenuous enough to argue that value is in the eyes of the beholder, and that any price can be justified if there are other investors willing to pay that price. That is patently absurd. Perceptions may be all that matter when the asset is a painting or a sculpture, but we do not and should not buy most assets for aesthetic or emotional reasons; we buy financial assets for the cash flows we expect to receive from them. Consequently, perceptions of value have to be backed up by reality, which implies that the price we pay for any asset should reflect the cash flows it is expected to generate. The models of valuation described in this book attempt to relate value to the level of, uncertainty about and expected growth in these cash flows.
There are many aspects of valuation where we can agree to disagree, including estimates of true value and how long it will take for prices to adjust to that true value. But there is one point on which there can be no disagreement. Asset prices cannot be justified by merely using the argument that there will be other investors around who will pay a higher price in the future. That is the equivalent of playing a very expensive game of
musical chairs, where every investor has to answer the question, "Where will I be when the music stops?” before playing. The problem with investing with the expectation that there will be a bigger fool around to sell an asset to, when the time comes, is that you might end up being the biggest fool of all.
Inside the Valuation Process
There are two extreme views of the valuation process. At one end are those who believe that valuation, done right, is a hard science, where there is little room for analyst views or human error. At the other are those who feel that valuation is more of an art, where savvy analysts can manipulate the numbers to generate whatever result they want. The truth does lies somewhere in the middle and we will use this section to consider three components of the valuation process that do not get the attention they deserve – the bias that analysts bring to the process, the uncertainty that they have to grapple with and the complexity that modern technology and easy access to information have introduced into valuation.
Value first, Valuation to follow: Bias in Valuation
We almost never start valuing a company with a blank slate. All too often, our views on a company are formed before we start inputting the numbers into the models that we use and not surprisingly, our conclusions tend to reflect our biases. We will begin by considering the sources of bias in valuation and then move on to evaluate how bias manifests itself in most valuations. We will close with a discussion of how best to minimize or at least deal with bias in valuations.
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Fundamental Analysis!!!
To arrive at Fair Valuation of a company what we require is lots of data, so that we are better equipped while forecasting its future income and hence paying and adequate price for it today!!! These data needs to be not only gathered but sorted and adjusted to level of your estimation too.
The sources to these data’s are endless; what’s more important is to set a pattern for our research activity based on which we can get data and analyze them one by one.
There are two different ways in which analyst may start their research activity.
1. Top –Down Research approach
2. Bottom-up Research approach
Top-Down Research approach: In this approach analyst doesn’t have any particular company at first to analyze but rather take a Countries Economy. Typically it starts with analyzing Economies across the comparable country, then analyzing Industries within the Economy, and then companies within the sector, finding an undervalued growth opportunity and then Investing. (please note I have used Analyzing the economy/industries/company with reference to a comparable, which simply put refers to one of the basic rule of analysis that when we analyze a company it cannot be done on a standalone basis and has to be relative, & compared with other economies/companies but of the same size, We cannot compare a developing or underdeveloped economy with a developed one, neither can we compare a multinational with a local business group irrespective of their presence in the same business.
Bottom-up Research approach: Against Top down in Bottom-up Research Analyst has a company or a script which is analyzed beforehand with comparable, moving then to the industrial performance and its growth prospective and then moving on to the Economy as a whole.
The sources to these data’s are endless; what’s more important is to set a pattern for our research activity based on which we can get data and analyze them one by one.
There are two different ways in which analyst may start their research activity.
1. Top –Down Research approach
2. Bottom-up Research approach
Top-Down Research approach: In this approach analyst doesn’t have any particular company at first to analyze but rather take a Countries Economy. Typically it starts with analyzing Economies across the comparable country, then analyzing Industries within the Economy, and then companies within the sector, finding an undervalued growth opportunity and then Investing. (please note I have used Analyzing the economy/industries/company with reference to a comparable, which simply put refers to one of the basic rule of analysis that when we analyze a company it cannot be done on a standalone basis and has to be relative, & compared with other economies/companies but of the same size, We cannot compare a developing or underdeveloped economy with a developed one, neither can we compare a multinational with a local business group irrespective of their presence in the same business.
Bottom-up Research approach: Against Top down in Bottom-up Research Analyst has a company or a script which is analyzed beforehand with comparable, moving then to the industrial performance and its growth prospective and then moving on to the Economy as a whole.
Need and Application of an analysis!!!!
One of the most debatable matters between Fundamental and Technical analyst has been the very need of doing an analysis. Why should we care about the monetary policy or fiscal policy of a country, why analyze a whole Industrial sector, why analyze a company’s management their accounts, forecast their future etc.? When we can buy/sell a stock and buy/sell it as soon we realize our profits (on the basis of demand and supply of stock or volume and trend of a stock or technical reasons discussed latter, I have written buy/sell here because in stock market you can sell a stock first even when you don’t own any stock and buy it latter at lower price and give the shares back, realizing the profit known as shorting).
Well this can be done purely on technical basis but not for a long term basis (I cannot predict what will be volumes or number of shares been traded in the market a year down the line) and by buying today selling tomorrow and repeating this over a period of time even in a stock which is doing good and is in upward trend we are reducing our profitability and exposing our self to the trading risk, only making our brokers rich.
The primary and most important reason for analyzing with such details and precision is to get the Fair value of a stock and the company that we are about to buy to be able to realize its future gains? This is the crux of value investing/Equity analysis. It’s actually more important for an investor that what price are you buy something than what are you buying. That is why Brand such as Reliance power was a bad buy when it was listed at 540 levels & satyam computers was a good buy at 40 levels even after all the hassle it has gone through.By saying that we need to buy something at fare price I mean the actual value of the shares or the company should be equal to market price. (Please note I am using value and price as two different terms as they are never the same, price is defined as the markets willingness to pay you “x” amount against one share of a company, by Value I mean fair price that I should receive today considering the future potential of a business).This makes it our Rule number 1 for our Investment
1) FAIR VALUATION
Now how to calculate the fair value of a share will be discussed over the topic before which I need to cover some prerequisite for arriving at fair valuation, which will be discussed in my next post.
Other Applications of Analysis
In financial world, Analysis is one of the most important aspects of the industry, not only in stock market/Equity market but also as a part of Economic research and forecast, Industrial research, Private Equity market (space where venture capitalist/other companies acquire other non-listed private company)
Well this can be done purely on technical basis but not for a long term basis (I cannot predict what will be volumes or number of shares been traded in the market a year down the line) and by buying today selling tomorrow and repeating this over a period of time even in a stock which is doing good and is in upward trend we are reducing our profitability and exposing our self to the trading risk, only making our brokers rich.
The primary and most important reason for analyzing with such details and precision is to get the Fair value of a stock and the company that we are about to buy to be able to realize its future gains? This is the crux of value investing/Equity analysis. It’s actually more important for an investor that what price are you buy something than what are you buying. That is why Brand such as Reliance power was a bad buy when it was listed at 540 levels & satyam computers was a good buy at 40 levels even after all the hassle it has gone through.By saying that we need to buy something at fare price I mean the actual value of the shares or the company should be equal to market price. (Please note I am using value and price as two different terms as they are never the same, price is defined as the markets willingness to pay you “x” amount against one share of a company, by Value I mean fair price that I should receive today considering the future potential of a business).This makes it our Rule number 1 for our Investment
1) FAIR VALUATION
Now how to calculate the fair value of a share will be discussed over the topic before which I need to cover some prerequisite for arriving at fair valuation, which will be discussed in my next post.
Other Applications of Analysis
In financial world, Analysis is one of the most important aspects of the industry, not only in stock market/Equity market but also as a part of Economic research and forecast, Industrial research, Private Equity market (space where venture capitalist/other companies acquire other non-listed private company)
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Most important Anlaysis
With an assumption that we are here to analyse Equity value of a company i.e. the business of which share is underlying asset off, I have to safely assume that we all are clear with basics of accounting and finance, I will still try to cover up basic as much as I can.
Before we start analysing a script or a share I think the most fruitful exercise would be to analyse ourselves as an individual and our objective from this, it’s obvious that we all have a common objective of earning profits but we all are different individuals and carry different belief and concept about this market. Many or in fact all of us at some time or other has hoped/imagined that the script we just bought would fetch us hundred times profit if not thousands. I wouldn't say that can never happen but buying and hoping script goes up isn't always fruitful. I come across many people who say “I don’t put my money in stock market any-more because whenever I did, the moment I did the stock prices tanked down, guess we are not made for each other.” I generally don’t react to it.
The best thing to start out would be to set our objectives straight to be able to strategies our way out
· What Am I here for?
· What kind of patience level do I have?
· What can be the time period of your investments?If your answers to these three questions are 1) here to make quick bucks, 2)no patience level, 3)less than one year/shorter the better, then you can safely put yourself in traders category and will require to develop a different set of skills (There is nothing wrong in being under traders horizon against the conventional belief, it’s just the skills require to succeed in the market with this object would be different (known as technical analysis) than what we are talking about here. (I am still learning about technical analysis and would add a blog on it soon.)
If your answers to these questions are 1) I am here to make money I don’t mind if it takes time as long as I learn from it too. 2) I have Patience, but doesn't mean I am stupid. 3) As long as the company is earning/sharing profits and growth prospectus is high I don’t mind 2yrs 5yrs 10yrs 20yrs…. Then you will need skills called as fundamental skills to analyse and can put yourself in the horizon of Investors.
There is nothing wrong in having both answers and objectives, ultimately whatever makes money for us….i put myself in both the categories too but then my portfolio is clearly divided into 25-75 horizon not more than 25% with a trading objective and out of that not more than 10% for speculative reasons if not all with a logical trading view. But before I did that I had to make sure I understand both views of analysis and rules of both the game which are like two very different animals. You too can design your own portfolio weight-age and put money accordingly till the time you are clear with the reasons for your call.
With the objectives clear we can then proceed to see what does the most intelligent people on the wall- Street does and how can we all share the title of an Analyst.
Welcome!!!
Equity Analysis/ Security Analysis/Value Investment/Fundamental Analysis ……Call it by any name it will still remain one of the most interesting and important aspect of Financial Industry at least to my opinion, In-fact this topic is the sole reason for my presence in the financial Industry. Quickly I will break the analysis part into
• Need and Application of Analysis
• Analysis – Top down & Bottom up (Economic, Industry, Company),Financial Statement Analysis, Ratio Analysis .....
• Valuation & its Need
• Equity Value, Enterprise Value, terminal Value
• Methods of Valuation –DCF, Relative Valuation…
• Financial Modeling
If you have just started learning about this subject don’t worry about the terminologies I have used here they might sound complicated but It’s actually the nature of the Financial world to make simplest of thing sound as complicated as they can, guess makes them feel sophisticated and intelligent. Had to include the list here so that the outline can be clear for everyone. I am sure I will be able to take you down with this topic as swiftly as possible as my mentor (Dheeraj Vaidya) did it for me Thanks to him. Cheers to you all!!!
• Need and Application of Analysis
• Analysis – Top down & Bottom up (Economic, Industry, Company),Financial Statement Analysis, Ratio Analysis .....
• Valuation & its Need
• Equity Value, Enterprise Value, terminal Value
• Methods of Valuation –DCF, Relative Valuation…
• Financial Modeling
If you have just started learning about this subject don’t worry about the terminologies I have used here they might sound complicated but It’s actually the nature of the Financial world to make simplest of thing sound as complicated as they can, guess makes them feel sophisticated and intelligent. Had to include the list here so that the outline can be clear for everyone. I am sure I will be able to take you down with this topic as swiftly as possible as my mentor (Dheeraj Vaidya) did it for me Thanks to him. Cheers to you all!!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







